Locum doctor VAT: Government reverses course as businesses grapple with historic refund claims
Just as employment businesses and umbrella companies begin to navigate the consequences of HMRC’s revised treatment of locum doctors, the Government has announced another change.
From 1st May 2027, the VAT exemption for the provision of locum doctors is set to be withdrawn, meaning affected supplies will generally become subject to VAT at 20% once again.
For these businesses, this is more than another legislative amendment. Many are still assessing historic VAT refund claims, managing customer expectations and considering the impact on input VAT recovery. The latest announcement adds another layer of complexity to an area that has already proved challenging for suppliers and their customers alike.
How did we get here?
Historically, HMRC regarded the provision of locum doctors by employment businesses as a taxable supply of staff, subject to VAT at 20%.
However, following the First-tier Tribunal decision in Isle of Wight NHS Foundation Trust, HMRC accepted that certain supplies of registered medical practitioners acting as deputies could qualify for VAT exemption under Item 5, Group 7, Schedule 9 of the VAT Act 1994.
Importantly, HMRC has also expressly confirmed that the exemption extends to umbrella companies making eligible supplies of registered locum doctors, meaning it is not restricted to traditional employment agencies.
This represented a significant development for businesses supplying locum doctors, particularly those working with NHS organisations and other healthcare providers. It also raised important questions about VAT charged historically and whether businesses should seek refunds from HMRC.
Another change from May 2027
In Revenue and Customs Brief 14 (2026), HMRC has confirmed that the Government intends to repeal the exemption for the provision of a deputy for a registered medical practitioner, with effect from 1st May 2027, subject to the necessary legislation being enacted.
As a result, supplies of locum doctors that constitute supplies of staff will generally become subject to VAT at 20% once again.
Importantly, the change will not affect supplies that qualify independently for the medical care exemption, including certain out-of-hours healthcare services.
For employment businesses and umbrella companies, this means another review of contractual arrangements, VAT accounting procedures and pricing, particularly where contracts extend beyond April 2027.
Historic VAT refunds remain a complex issue
Although the Government has announced the withdrawal of the exemption, HMRC has confirmed that this will not prevent businesses, including umbrella companies making qualifying supplies, from pursuing refunds of VAT overdeclared historically.
However, deciding whether and when to submit a claim is far from straightforward.
Many businesses are still considering their position, particularly where customers have not requested repayment of VAT previously charged.
A claim under section 80 of the VAT Act 1994 may give rise to questions about whether the business has borne the economic cost of the VAT or passed it on to its customers. HMRC’s unjust enrichment provisions must therefore be considered carefully, alongside the commercial and contractual implications of any refund.
There is also the question of input VAT recovery. Where supplies previously treated as taxable are subsequently recognised as exempt, businesses may need to revisit their partial exemption calculations and repay input VAT previously recovered.
Consequently, while historic refund claims may appear straightforward, the overall financial benefit to a business may be significantly lower than the VAT originally overdeclared once potential input VAT adjustments and customer reimbursements are taken into account.
These issues make it essential to consider historic refund claims in the round, rather than simply calculating the output VAT previously declared.
The challenge for employment businesses, umbrella companies and their customers
The successive changes in HMRC’s position have created considerable practical difficulties.
Businesses have had to revisit historic transactions, consider refund claims, assess their input VAT recovery and communicate the implications to customers, all while continuing to manage their day-to-day VAT obligations.
Customers, meanwhile, may have different expectations about whether historic VAT should be refunded, depending on their own VAT recovery position and contractual arrangements.
With a further legislative change now approaching, businesses face the additional challenge of preparing to reintroduce VAT on affected supplies from May 2027.
This creates uncertainty, additional administrative costs and potentially significant cash flow implications for both suppliers and their customers.
How Gravita can help
At Gravita, our VAT specialists have been working closely with employment businesses to help them navigate this evolving area of VAT legislation and HMRC policy.
Our work includes assessing whether historic supplies qualify for exemption, preparing and submitting section 80 refund claims, considering unjust enrichment and partial exemption adjustments, and advising on the commercial implications of potential refunds to customers.
We can also assist umbrella companies in reviewing their historic VAT treatment and determining whether they have potential refund claims arising from qualifying supplies of registered locum doctors.
Looking ahead, we are helping businesses understand how the proposed changes from May 2027 will affect their contracts, pricing and future VAT compliance.
With historic refund opportunities still available and another change approaching, employment businesses and umbrella companies should review their position carefully, particularly where statutory time limits could affect their ability to recover VAT previously overdeclared.
If your business supplies locum doctors and would like to understand the implications of these developments, please contact Gravita’s VAT team.
Similar Insights
Overseas suppliers and UK VAT: Could the latest reform widen the VAT gap?
Could your charity be paying too much VAT or unknowingly creating a VAT liability?
What the Bolt VAT case means for digital platforms
Sign up to Gravita's latest updates and newsletters
Stay up-to-date with our event invites, latest news and updates, straight from Gravita's experts.