Getting employee incentives right from the start
Keeping your best people motivated and committed to your business isn’t always just about salary. Whether you’re looking to attract new talent, reward a key employee or plan for the future of your business, the right incentive can make a real difference. But with options ranging from cash bonuses to shares and share schemes, how do you know which approach is right?
In this article, Clare Boden explores the different ways to reward and retain key employees, the tax implications to consider and why getting the structure right from the start can help protect both your business and your people.
Getting employee incentives right from the start
Employee incentives usually come up because a promising candidate wants more than the salary budget allows, a trusted director is approached by competitors, or the founder wants to step back knowing the business is in good hands.
It’s easy to jump straight to shares, options or a cash bonus. Start instead with your goals, what matters to the employee and how you’ll handle a change of plan, then work through the structure and tax implications.
Match the incentive to your business goals
Imagine an engineering business whose owner hopes to step back in five years. The operations director runs much of it, knows the customers and has the team’s confidence, but cannot afford a buyout. An annual bonus rewards performance without addressing succession. A stake could form part of the answer, although funding and the handover still need a plan.
Now consider a consultancy recruiting a commercial director to grow towards a sale. The founder has spent ten years building a business worth, say, £2 million and is happy to share future growth, but not existing value. Growth shares could let the director participate above an agreed hurdle, subject to careful valuation and share rights. The discussion becomes practical: what growth is expected, over what period, and what might the director receive?
In either case, everyone needs to understand what happens if the director leaves after two years or a sale is delayed. Employees need to see how their contribution connects to a potential reward.
Plan ahead for shares and options
Ownership is worth considering before you’re ready to offer shares. Your share structure and shareholder arrangements affect what’s possible, particularly when investors arrive or owners have different plans. Waiting until someone threatens to leave risks a rushed negotiation.
Growth shares are one possibility; options may offer another, potentially with a different tax outcome. Where conditions are met, Enterprise Management Incentive (EMI) options granted at market value may mean no income tax or National Insurance on growth when exercised, with capital gains tax applying on sale instead (Business Asset Disposal Relief may also be available, subject to its conditions). The company may qualify for a corporation tax deduction on exercise without paying a cash bonus.
Check the tax details before you commit
But shares aren’t automatically tax-efficient. If the director receives growth shares worth more than they pay, income tax could arise before there’s cash to meet it. Missing an appropriate restricted-share tax election can expose part of a later return to income tax rather than capital gains tax. The business may also face PAYE obligations and employer National Insurance. Checking eligibility, valuation, documents and deadlines before anything is promised or signed helps avoid unexpected bills for both sides.
You don’t need a scheme in mind to start the conversation. Where the business is heading and who you want alongside you will help establish which incentive, if any, makes sense. We can help explore that, including the tax implications, before you commit.
How Gravita can help
Choosing the right employee incentive scheme means finding an approach that rewards your people while supporting your business goals.
At Gravita, our tax and advisory experts can help you explore your options, from EMI schemes to growth shares, understand the tax implications and put the right arrangements in place to reward and retain key employees.
Thinking about introducing an employee incentive scheme?
Get in touch with Clare Boden and our team to discuss your options and find out how we can help.
Similar Insights
Getting the structure of your business right so that it is ready for future investment
Your first audit: What to expect and how to prepare
PAYE: Everything employers need to know about payroll, deductions and employee benefits
Sign up to Gravita's latest updates and newsletters
Stay up-to-date with our event invites, latest news and updates, straight from Gravita's experts.